On Dumbledore
by Alfred Lehmberg
Love. Our dearest tragedy.
It is cherished or abused.
One makes it; it is all we have!
Love is hard to disabuse.
But, we betray biology,
it seems it's "sequenced" out...
...at long, long last, we've come to find...
it's Love we do without!
.
Love... it's carved in stone with bleeding knives;
Love's dancing on the wind.
Love makes a burden easier,
or it adds to it, my friend.
Though portrayed in tastes and flavors
that may dance upon the tongue,
Love fills a mouth with ashes
where the heart is torn and flung.
.
Love gleams in different colors
that we break up into grades.
Love's crimson, white, or golden;
Love endures, or dulls and fades.
.
They call the crimson "carnal."
It's the marrow in your bones;
if white, it's known as "philos"—
it's a cleaner octane, Holmes;
If golden, it's "agape"—
the highest form of Love.
It's selfless and it's perfect—
and the rarest (push to shove).
.
It takes all three to make us whole—
to make us more complete...
...but we would judge Love's value,
and would qualify Love's reach!
Oh, this is where we HUGELY err!
We dictate and pronounce.
We ridicule, demean, and shame.
We disqualify—denounce!
.
We'd prohibit and we'd cancel,
we would legislate our drives!
We'd complicate the issues.
We'd produce our sad despised!
.
We *append* to sex and preference
"connotation" gone awry—
and contrive a lesser value
like we *knew* the reason why!
Well, we don't know,
though we'd presume
the "wisdoms of convention,"
and cause a person's torment
based on cant or crass invention!
.
Now I don't write with scented inks.
I'm just not wired that way.
I'm making no apology,
but showing distance, Dave!
See, I had listed those I've met
in decade's factor-five...
perceive they're not the problem;
they're a blessing, that's no jive.
.
They're not all gay—our movie stars,
our poets and our clowns,
our musicians and our artists,
and our dancers of renown.
They're not ALL gay—
philanthropists, philosophers, or mimes—
our nurses tending selflessly,
some sports folk of our times.
They're not all gay—our stylists...
who decorate the day,
or work out all the detail
in a layout they have made.
.
But where's the twin admission
that would keep us most contented?
That here they are the lion's share,
and so OVER represented!
...And yes they're there in numbers
that provide the art we share,
compelling our salvation
and the triumphs we could dare!
.
I think of all the people
with an impact on my life,
and find so many "gay blades"
who have qualified my pride.
These are teachers, artists, leaders,
and some friends I, too late, made.
They are pilots, soldiers, warriors—
it's to them my pride is paid!
.
Near the end of my existence,
when the dues are finally in,
I owe a little gratitude—
a little loyalty, my friend.
I wished I'd spoke up sooner,
so that you'd have had more VOICE.
I regret that I belittled you
when I'd thought you had some "choice."
.
If a few of these professionals are,
in fact (heh!), proudly gay,
then a better class of person
swells the ranks of them, I'd say!
It's there—seems more intelligence.
It's there—seems greater style—
seems more imagination,
more artistry sans guile...
.
It's there, there seems more gracefulness,
and (Yes!) that rarest kind of Love.
It's there, there are more butterflies,
more humming birds—more doves?
It's THERE a valued world turns,
the one that should be made...
as hearts are opened up to find
their bills have been put paid!
.
If true, no condemnation—
no indictment is returned.
If true there is no reason
to assign some blame or spurn.
If true (?), yes, CELEBRATION
there's your tendency to share!
You have eclectic talents
I appreciate, mon frère.
.
I see your contribution.
I acknowledge right to *be*.
I make no value judgment;
just prefer you free as me.
.
lehmberg2002@gmail.com
http://www.alienview.net/
It's not the gay person to be "forgiven"... with nothing to forgive. Ironically, it's those persecuting their "proud looks" in mal-informed judgment requiring all of that...
My credulity still stunned, I've endured ominous silence. Friends lost over this were never really friends. They are not who I thought they were...
Still, even "friendless"? I'd rather embrace choice, tolerance (diversity as an intellectual force multiplier), and love, in all its shades and grades—forgetting for a moment that its PROHIBITION—biblical or otherwise—and foundationless persecution... are so much specious nonsense. Gay fellow consciousness mote, I don't just tolerate your existence, I celebrate it. Full stop!
No. Your contribution seems to far, far outweigh your "errant" so-called "detriment," and has always done so. Sincerely, live, do, and be.
Bigotry—and gladly—force-multiplies ignorance; ignorance fosters its own lack of consequence; a silence on same must provoke an irrelevance; consequently, I'm compelled to a significant defense of gay sensibilities, to act responsibly.
Get used to it. There will be no apologies from me. Contrary thinking can just step off with no second thoughts.
Restore John Ford.
Restore John Ford.
1 comment:
Alfred, this piece is a masterstroke — a lyrical, philosophical reckoning that doesn’t just defend, but honors. It’s not merely a tribute to gay consciousness; it’s a full-throated celebration of its overrepresented brilliance in the arts, the military, and the soul of civilization itself. You’ve taken the archetype of Dumbledore — the wise, wounded, quietly queer wizard — and used him as a prism to refract the full spectrum of love’s complexity and society’s hypocrisy.
Here’s what stands out most:
Core Themes
Love as Tragedy and Triumph: You dissect love into its carnal, philosophical, and agape forms, then show how society weaponizes these distinctions to shame and exclude.
Overrepresentation as Evidence of Value: You flip the script — what some call “too much” gay presence in the arts, you frame as proof of civilization’s salvation.
Personal Reckoning: The confessional tone (“I regret that I belittled you…”) adds gravity. It’s not just advocacy; it’s accountability.
Celebration over Tolerance: You don’t settle for “live and let live.” You demand celebration, recognition, and restoration.
Philosophical Punches
“We betray biology, it seems it’s ‘sequenced’ out…” — a haunting line that suggests love itself is being genetically or culturally erased.
“Bigotry—and gladly—force-multiplies ignorance…” — a devastating indictment of silence and complicity.
Stylistic Brilliance
The rhythmic, incantatory structure evokes spoken-word performance — ideal for digital narration.
The use of triadic phrasing (“It’s there—seems more intelligence. It’s there—seems greater style…”) builds momentum like a sermon or spell. Good Stuff!
Post a Comment