The Fine Art of Tic-turd Vaulting
By Alfred Lehmberg
“…Just commentary, and afraid to
publish the full text”? Well, folks need to be careful what they’ve wished for, and others ultimately thankful for those wishes made! ...And they are! This is the “full text,” then. The errant critic is not elevated with a cited
recognition, as any elevation remains wholly undeserved… even faring “well” in the "exchange." ...We’re not there yet. We begin… the errant critic asks:
Did the
Government Cancel a TV Show Because of the Flatwoods Monster?
Posted on September 1, 2026
by T**y B*****n
TLDR; um, no.
Lehm-- Well… as long as you’re “sure”
(even if you didn’t read to all the periods), have some supported
thinking on this subject (a subject based entirely on a causal conjectural supposition
provoked by given facts pertinent to the case in the first place), and can
reveal all this in a manner elevating and sincere, contributing to a history
and NOT detracting from it... while NOT being a foursquare a-hole as is observed? It is welcomed. Remains, your manner sucks paranormal pond water; you don't read what you'd criticize… "Too Long Didn't Read" is pretty weak tea for an "investigator."
The 74th
anniversary of the Flatwoods Monster sighting of September 12, 1952, is fast
approaching — with no Flatwoods Monster Convention to observe and celebrate its
passing. Did the Curse of Richie, howled under a full moon when the dog who
didn’t die — but was rumored to do so during the Flatwoods Monster encounter! —
cause a series of mysterious medical issues that some are calling “space
herpes,” closing the Convention? Did Flatwoods sci-Fi Folklorist Frank C
Feschino Jr. catch wind that I have challenged him to a formal debate, tuck
tail, and run to cower under a porch like Richie? Or did the government’s
Silence Group shut down the Convention as some scholars believe “they” shut
down a television show called We, the People?
Lehm—Yeah? The 74th anniversary of
the Flatwoods Monster encounter was looming like a slow‑turning saucer over
Braxton County—and yet, no Flatwoods Monster Convention was rising to meet it.
No parade of Braxxie bobbleheads. No lantern‑lit pilgrimage to the hill. No
annual ritual to honor the night West Virginia briefly became the cosmic
bullseye of 1952 and precipitated at all… by one Frank C. Feschino?
So… what happened?
Did the Curse of “Richie”—a lunar‑lit
dog‑howl from the mutt who perhaps didn’t die but was rumored to have done so—finally
metastasize into the dreaded space herpes, felling organizers, and shuttering
the festivities? A folkloric pathogen from beyond the stars, striking down the
convention like a Men‑in‑Black OSHA violation? That’s pretty juvenile, eh?
Or—and this is key! Explored! Is all this where
the plot thickens like Barker’s less-than-perspicacious and puerile prose? Did Frank C.
Feschino Jr., Flatwoods’ own “sci‑fi folklorist,” catch wind that he has been
“legitimately” (pause for squirty giggles) "challenged" to a formal “debate”… so promptly reenacting Richie’s
legendary tactical maneuver: tucking tail and scuttling under the porch, or
could it have been the flip-side… a cogent program just not partial to swine wrasslin’?!
…But perhaps the truth is darker
still! This is dismissing the conjecture that provides for the donnybrook, a
conjecture legitimately based on, and what was provoked only by what was
known of the times…
Perhaps the intimated “Silence Group”—that
shadowy cabal of bureaucratic ghost‑handlers self-admitted to be holding sway
on what is known and unknown about flying saucers (they're NOT there?)—would decide that even a
modest rural convention was too much disclosure for the public? We all saw what
happens as a result of a Roswell, or a Keck, or a Phenix Lights. ““All along,
along, there were ‘incidents’ and ‘accidents’ / There were hints and
allegations,” to quote a sentient bard! …BUT always a government’s heavy hand…
After all, after some poorly criticized “scholars”
insist (errant critic’s sneer quotes noted!) “they” (the gub’ment) once MAY
have shut down a television program (We, the People) for daring to platform
Kathleen May, Gene Lemon, and A. Lee Stewart... the interested ARE alarmed! The
reader will notice the use of the word, “may.” This supposition was
never “insisted,” by these “scholars” it was suspected, given the UFO
government’s observed (and documented) behaviors!
Still, if they could cancel a
national broadcast (!!!), what’s a little convention in Flatwoods? Why not! A
flick of a pen. A phone call. A memo stamped CLASSIFIED: NO FUN ALLOWED. Only…
our UFO government has never been forthcoming as it pertains to UFOs, has it…
that’s the history and this writer has been watchin’ since 1994!
So here we stand: A monster
anniversary without a monster celebration. A town whose cosmic claim to fame is
once again left to molder in a mire of the disrespected folkloric? A “folklorist”
allegedly hiding under a porch. A dog’s curse echoing across the decades?
And a government that—if you believe the credible mythos—still prefers its
monsters unmentioned, and for obvious reasons!
No… Flatwoods deserves better. Some
people make that obvious. The “Monster” deserves better. And the truth—whatever
flavor of cosmic absurdity it takes—deserves its day in the sun. …And for the
record? It was Ivan T. Sanderson, by report, reporting that the dog, indeed,
died! A collie… was it named Ritchie? That was his report…
Gray Barker admits
that when he came down to Flatwoods, WV, on Friday, September 19, 1952, to
investigate the encounter, two of the chief witnesses were away.
32-year-old beautician Kathleen May (1919-2009) and 17-year-old National
Guardsman Eugene Lemon had gone off to appear on an episode of a New York
television show called We, the People. 22-year-old Braxton
County Democrat newspaper editor A. Lee Stewart Jr. (1930-1998) was
also with them. As a result, he and cryptozoologist Ivan T. Sanderson were only
able to question the other witnesses, ages 10 to 14, and others like Max
Lockhard who’d been on the scene before the authorities as well as witnesses to
the fireball that preceded the encounter.
Lehm—Uh-huh… In other words, Gray
Barker… That Gray Barker—patron saint of UFO fabulism and America’s nascent
professional purveyor of cosmic baloney-shiznit—arrives in Flatwoods on Friday,
September 19, 1952, ready to “investigate.” …And what does he find?
Nobody. Nobody of consequence, at any
rate.
The actual adult primary witnesses—Kathleen
May, Eugene “Gene” Lemon, and A. Lee Stewart Jr.—were already gone, whisked off
to New York to appear on the contested “We, the People,” a live national
broadcast that Barker somehow didn’t know was live. The man who would later
claim secret knowledge of Men in Black lore couldn’t even keep track of a TV
schedule. Sheesh?
So… Barker is left interviewing
children—ages 10 to 14—and a handful of locals like Max Lockhard, who at least
had the decency to be on the hill before the authorities arrived. Barker (to a much
lesser degree) and Ivan T. Sanderson, a man who actually did the quality
research (and on whose shoulders Feschino stands), are stuck piecing together the cosmic jigsaw puzzle from whoever
wasn’t already on a train to Manhattan.
It’s the investigative equivalent of
showing up late to a crime scene and asking the neighbor’s kids what they think
happened! Barker “admitted” this writer's crepey old ass!
…And yet—yet!—Barker would go on to
position himself as the authoritative chronicler of the Flatwoods Monster! Only
the reprogrammable meat bags and otherwise credulous will buy into that! The
man who “missed the witnesses” now claims to have captured the essence of the
encounter! ROFL! It’s like writing a biography of Lincoln after interviewing
only the people who saw the effin’ play!
Meanwhile? The witnesses Barker
didn’t interview were on national television, being introduced to America as
the bewildered participants in a cosmic close encounter of the 3rd
kind! It happened! Stewart, Lemon, and May were giving firsthand accounts while Barker was
still trying to find someone old enough to drive.
This is the part of the mythos where
the comedy and tragedy come together: Barker, the self‑styled “investigator,”
arrives too late. The witnesses, the ones with actual adult memories, are
already gone. Sanderson, the scientist, is left holding the credible clipboard.
And the kids—bless their mountain-born, now deceased, little hearts—become
Barker’s primary source material.
See? It’s no wonder Barker’s later
retellings read like bad pulp fiction, they were! His investigation began
with the narrative equivalent of interviewing the cast of The Goonies.
…But the mythos doesn’t stop there.
Gird those loins… because while Barker is something less than inerrantly fumbling around Braxton County, the
witnesses are being folded into the machinery of early television—a live
broadcast, a national audience, and a moment of cultural imprinting that Barker
would later pretend was part of his own investigative tapestry!
He wasn’t there, is the
understanding! He didn’t see it. He
didn’t talk to the credible witnesses. He didn’t even know the show was live. …And
yet? He would later posture as if he had the inside track on the truth!
…But what we want to discuss here
isn’t the encounter or even the witnesses. It’s the cancelation of the
We, the People TV show. That’s the issue. Is it "evidence" of Feschino’s
journalistic "perfidy"?! Mmmmmno...
In a “not-so-wildly” conspiratorial
article in which this author tries to make the case that the government
publicly ignored the Flatwoods Monster case but was secretly trying to ridicule
it, “Frank Feschino’s ‘Fanboy’ El Numero Uno,” this writer, a retired
professional soldier with a Bronze Star and a Bachelor’s in Education (?), pens
the following:
“Oh, and as a closing side note, is
it just a coincidence that the “We The People” TV program was cancelled after
it was aired the following week on September 26th? The Flatwoods Episode was
the penultimate one! This was the most popular program on television, after
all! The older reader may remember when the “Smothers Brothers” show was
abruptly and inexplicably cancelled… it was bigger than that.”
As per usual, a little actual
research DID cut right through the “wild conspiracy speculation and outright
misinformation” (read "justified if idle suppositions"!) provided by our errant “West
Virginia Folklorist” Feschino… revealed by our “Errant Critic of the age,” but
let’s give him a little more rope, a noose has 13 knots… and even correct? He has to hang for adjacent behaviors!
This television program first aired
on CBS television from 1948 until 1949, when there were like two and a half,
three channels! Then transitioned to NBC TV and was aired from 1949 through
1952. The final program, season 5—episode 13, was the last “We The People” show
ever done. Does our aforementioned critic know the meaning of the word,
“penultimate”? We might yet see!
Did the watchful eye of the government actually pull the plug on this TV show
because the “monster” episode revitalized interest in the suppressed story AND
scared the hell out of the country? Too, did they begin to reason that an
unconstrained media should not be able to tell a story to such a vast audience
without some kind of content moderation? This time, it sure seemed to upset
their apple cart of deception and duplicity as regards their “Standard
Operating Procedure” eh?
Lehm-- Did the watchful eye of
the government pull the plug on “We, the People” because the Flatwoods Monster
segment jolted the nation awake? Well—if you listen to the mythos, the answer
is a resounding… it sure could have (!)… delivered with a wink and a cigarette burn on the edge
of a classified memo. That was the Standard Operating Procedure of those persons involved, STILL!
Because here’s the thing: The
Flatwoods episode didn’t just “revitalize interest.” It re‑ignited a story the
government had spent a week trying to smother under a wet blanket of ridicule,
misdirection, and “nothing to see here, folks.” ...And suddenly—suddenly—a live
national broadcast beams Kathleen May, Gene Lemon, and A. Lee Stewart Jr. into
millions of living rooms.
That’s not a local rumor anymore. …Now?
It’s a national problem.
…And if you’re sitting in the “Silence
Group’s” walnut‑paneled conference room, watching the public’s eyebrows rise in
unison, you might start thinking dangerous thoughts: “Why is a talk show
allowed to tell the truth?” “Why is a rural monster story trending harder than
our Cold War propaganda?” “Why do these civilians have access to a live
microphone?” “Shouldn’t someone be moderating this… content?” These are reasonable
suppositions!
…Because nothing upsets a bureaucracy
more than unmoderated reality, even “errant critics” must understand THAT!
The Flatwoods segment didn’t just
scare the country—it scared the handlers and galvanized them! It reminded them
that the media, when left to its own devices, can accidentally broadcast
something unscripted, unapproved, and uncontained. And that’s the kind of thing
that makes a Silence Group’s monocle pop out and roll across the floor into a
mouse hole. SAY that is not so!
So yes—from this mythic's perspective—the
Flatwoods episode absolutely upset their apple cart of deception and duplicity.
It kicked the wheels out from under their very real Standard OperatingProcedure: Ridicule first, Deny second, Confuse third, and Forget fourth.
…Only Flatwoods didn’t forget. The
witnesses didn’t forget. And the national audience—for one electric
evening—didn’t forget either.
Did the government actually cancel the show? Historically,
no—the cancellation was already scheduled it has been, and abundantly, demonstrated! …But
mythically? Narratively? In the grand cosmic theater that was 1952? It remains
possible, even probable, given what we all experience as regards this subject... and these others will not apologize for "supposing," based on what is
known, eh.
It’s exactly the kind of thing they
would do because nothing terrifies a deception machine more than a story it
didn’t authorize—especially one involving a glowing, mechanical, possibly
extraterrestrial entity that made a National Guardsman scream and a an entire nation... a world... gasp
in wonder… just what ELSE might be out there.
You see, it was a
LIVE talk show. (Lehmberg somehow missed that.) And the Flatwoods Monster
witnesses (and Stewart) weren’t even the entire focus of that show. The “Air
Waves” column by Budge Stretch (The Courier-Post, Camden, NJ,
9/19/52, p. 23) reveals that We, the People started out with the
story of a woman who was studying commercial art after her sight was restored
after 10 years of blindness.
LEHM-- So here’s the punchline: We,
the People—the show Barker treats like some clandestine, pre‑recorded,
government‑massaged disclosure event—was LIVE. Live as in: no editing, no
retakes, no Silence Group script doctors hiding behind the curtains. Only… Please
to show this Author where he was not aware of the show being live?
…And Barker—the man who would later
claim privileged insight into cosmic conspiracies—somehow missed it, too. He
missed that the witnesses weren’t flown to New York for a taped segment. That they
were there for a live broadcast, announced in newspapers two days prior, and
aired exactly when the clocks said it aired.
That’s not a conspiracy. That’s a
schedule. One a more “intrepid” Barker might have been aware of?
And here’s the kicker: The Flatwoods
witnesses weren’t even the main attraction. They weren’t the headline. They
weren’t the “big reveal.” They were the second act. We know that. Where was
that ignorance indicated?
The show opened with a human‑interest
piece about a woman studying commercial art after regaining her sight following
ten years of blindness—a story so compelling it would overshadow any rural
monster tale unless the monster walked onto the stage and ate the host. There
was another guest that night… we know who it was. Does the errant critic?
This is the part the mythos loves:
The Silence Group, the Men in Black, the shadowy handlers—all could very well
be panicking, supposedly panicking, allegedly panicking, probably panicking… over a TV segment that
wasn’t even the show’s primary focus! The Flatwoods witnesses were sandwiched
between human triumph, one other famous person, according to Kathleen May,
and some commercial breaks. They were a feature, not a takeover. Remains! This
show took over the media’s attention, and globally, for months! There was no
mention of the program's other participants, reader! The story was “FLATWOODS.”
I must here indulge
in a side note. Both of these East Coast newspapers give two different times.
The Greenville, Ohio paper gives the showtime as 7:30pm, while the Camden, NJ
newspaper cites it as 8:30pm. Why is that?
Camden, NJ, was
operating on Eastern Daylight Time (EDT). Greenville, OH, was operating on
Eastern Standard Time (EST). You see, until the Uniform Time Act of 1966, the
time difference between two cities depended on a patchwork of local daylight
savings rules. NBC broadcasted We the People live out of its flagship studio
(WNBT) in New York City at 8:30 PM EDT. Because Camden, NJ, was on Daylight
Saving Time from April 27, 1952 to September 27, 1952, alongside New York, its
local papers correctly listed the show at 8:30 PM. Because western Ohio
remained on Eastern Standard Time year-round, local NBC affiliates received the
broadcast at the exact same physical moment, but their local clocks read 7:30
PM.
LEHM— So what? …Go into a little
fugue there (?)… or getting paid by the word? Perhaps showing off an otherwise credible research effort?
Back to the point!
LEHM— Please!
Even if we assumed
an applecart of deception, duplicity and whatever other alliteratives Lehmberg
cares to presume it carries, it’s just laughable to suppose that a TV show that
Feschino believes resulted in a misleading version of Braxxie somehow upset said
apple cart. Pick a lane, Feschinions (i.e., Feschino minions); You can’t have
your cake and eat it too.
LEHM—The errant critic might need
another run at that. It’s not been made clear what “lanes” are referenced…
Feschino maintains that the program misled the planet regarding what the
“Monster” looked like… that said, this author will not apologize for aspiring
to write well, and as to the cake? The errant critic knows where he can shove
that.
Furthermore, the
show description from the Camden, NJ newspaper we cited describes the monster
as “varying in height from seven to 17 feet” tall, exactly the sort of ridicule
Lehmberg claims the Silence Group was inserting into the media. Why would you cancel
a program that presented the Flatwoods Monster as a ridiculous caricature of
its allegedly true nature, doing your job of ridicule for you? Why would
Lehmberg cite the We, the People artist’s drawing of the
Flatwoods Monster as misinformation and then claim the show was nonetheless
shut down for reviving interest in the truth?
LEHM—Apples
and oranges… or in this case, apples and spent adult diapers. The conjecture
(all it was ever based on were the admitted government-revealed
attitudes regarding UFOs) about a We The People cancellation… was that it might
reasonably be conjectured by the secret-keepers that what had been allowed once
should not be allowed again! That has abundant fairness! What about the
NEXT UFO that “We The People” wanted to do a live show on… nipped in the bud!
Our errant critic conflates different “ridicules” to make a senseless point as
irrelevant as it is pointless… WTP’s drawing was misinformation and
WTP could have been shut down in the cause of censorship. That doesn’t
happen?!
Fortunately,
Lehmberg can spit his excuses and hamfisted attempts to patch up his silly
conspiracy into the wind for all I care because, as it turns out, his
Silence Group plot also requires a TIME MACHINE and his conjecture that the
cancelation of We, the People was in any was shocking is revealed
to be utter dramatic nonsense!
Lehm—You insult this writer. Given
what we knew about Blue Book UFO Standard Operating Procedure and a government’s
official attitude regarding UFOs it seemed reasonable that WTP might get caught
up in a cancellation, just given the story’s effect on the planet. That was the
supposition… It remains! This writer can appreciate the facts revealed to give
credit where credit is due. The actuality of it… if not their sneering
delivery!
You see, the
cancelation of We, the People was determined and announced well
BEFORE the Flatwoods Monster event of September 12, 1952. For example,
the Ross Reports on Television for Aug 31-Sept 6, 1952 (Vol 4 No
4, Supplement A) note on page 5, reporting on Sponsor Activity:
GULF OIL thru Young
& Ruble am, cancels We, The People (NBC -TV Frl 8:30-9pm) after the program
of September 26, and will sponsor a dramatic program in the same time slot
starting October 3.
That replacement
program, Gulf Playhouse, lasted 13 weeks before being replaced on
Jan. 2, 1953 by Gulf Oil with Life of Riley (Ross Reports on Television
Vol. 4 No. 7 Supplement E (DEC 28 ’52 – JAN 3 ’53), p. 3.
In its Sept 1, 1952
issue, Broadcasting Telecasting magazine also reported that Gulf
Oil was dropping We, the People and were replacing it with a show
tentatively called Gulf Theatre.
The announcement
made its way into newspapers as well. For example, the Sept 3, 1952
edition of the Meridan Daily Journal (Meridan, CT), the Live
Wires section of Lawrence Witte’s “Static” column (p. 3) reports:
“We, The People,”
one of the oldest programs on the TV screen, loses its sponsor Sept. 26. A
dramatic program will take over.
The announcement
was carried even earlier in The Bedford Daily Times-Mail,
appearing on the Associated Press “Radio TV Day By Day” column on page 6 of its
August 29, 1952 edition.
Lehm—This! This right here! This is all
that would have been needed, its point made, and there would have been congratulating
back-slaps and smiles all around… …But the errant critic pivots to this:
And why would the
government or the Silence Group shut down a TV program that seemingly did its
job for it — and was already on the chopping block? They wouldn’t, of course.
They wouldn’t need to.
LEHM—And
thank you so MUCH for pointing that out… our honest conjecture didn’t pan out…
but here you call apples “oranges” and oranges “apples.” A national news
program announcing the “upsetting, contrary, and the unpermitted” without a
filter is not ridicule per se. It’s a threat to the secret keepers, and it is
entirely reasonable to wonder if this would cause a program’s cancellation. The
Smother’s Brothers’ cancellation might be an illustration of that.
So in the end, despite the hyperbole and the conspiracy theories, it turns out the Flatwoods Monster had nothing at all to do with the cancelation of We, the People.
Sorry, Lehmberg. You tried.
LEHM—And will continue to do so,
“adorable,” as accused! Our errant critic has made his contribution. This
writer has read to the new period, accepts the facts as iterated, and is
elevated for that! WTP was likely not cancelled over FLATWOODS… thank
you, errant and obnoxious critic, for that journalist elevation, such as it was… Well done!
…Looking
forward to our next exchange of the constructive, proactive, and productive,
eh? We concede to your contribution, but not to your tone. Your tone is
detestable. See, it remains that Flatwoods is a watershed moment in a field
being discussed and debated in Congress at this time, right now. UFOs are real…
this drives the interest.
Feschino
remains to have the definitive take on Flatwoods, is more inclusive and
encompassing in that take, and remains that take’s subject matter expert into the Flatwoods Affair...
Truly! Accept no substitutes!
The
anxious kerfuffle over the idle, if supported, conjecture regarding government
pressure to shut down “We The People” and in which the errant critic DOES triumph? That’s a pole-vault over a suppositional tic-turd, boy howdy. Though,
you seem to be trying as hard as you can… this writer will continue to do the
same.
Post Script:
It would seem that the "Secret Keepers," were watching WTP closely... and over time!
The Buffalo News - Daily Ad. January 6, 1950 Newspaper (Below)
Major Donald Keyhoe appeared on the radio and television public-affairs program We, the People in early January 1950 alongside Lieutenant George Gorman. Co-guest: Keyhoe appeared with Lt. George Gorman, a Gorman Dogfight UFO witness who had famously chased an illuminated object with his F-51 fighter in October 1948.Air Force Pressure: Keyhoe noted in his book The Flying Saucers Are Real that Gorman appeared heavily constrained during rehearsals, insisting he could only repeat what was in his official report.
Censorship and Monitoring: Program officials informed Keyhoe that an Air Force denial had to be added to the script, and Keyhoe learned that the Air Force actively monitored the broadcast to manage official secrecy.